Skip to main content

43 Newbury Drive

Newmarket, ON L3Y 4P9 — Legal Two-Unit Home for First-Time Buyers & Investors

$749,888

For Sale
5 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
900 Sq Ft
4 Spaces Parking
42.75 × 98 Lot Dimensions

About This Home

Attention First-Time Home Buyers! Live in the lower unit and let the upper unit, with an estimated rental income of approximately $3,000 per month, cover your monthly carrying costs (see disclaimer below). For investors, this legal two-unit home offers an estimated combined rental potential of approximately $5,000 per month ($3,000 upper unit and $2,000 lower unit), creating an excellent opportunity to generate income while building long-term equity (buyers to complete their own due diligence).


With over $100,000 invested in renovations, this vacant legal two-unit home is move-in ready, allowing you to choose your own tenants or lease both units from day one. The bright upper level features three bedrooms, an updated eat-in kitchen, spacious open-concept living and dining areas, oversized windows, and modern finishes throughout.


The finished lower level offers its own kitchen, spacious living area, two bedrooms, a full bathroom, laundry, and separate entrance, making it ideal for rental income, extended family, or multi-generational living.


Situated in an established Newmarket neighbourhood, you'll enjoy easy access to parks, schools, shopping, public transit, everyday amenities, and major commuter routes throughout York Region and the GTA.


Disclaimer: Rental income and mortgage payment examples are provided for illustrative purposes only and are not guaranteed. For illustration, a $600,000 mortgage at TD Bank's posted 5-year variable rate available at the time of writing would have an estimated monthly payment of approximately $2,965. Rental values, interest rates, financing terms and ownership expenses are subject to change. Buyers are encouraged to verify all figures through their own due diligence and consult their lender and other professional advisors.


Rental Items: Hot Water Heater.

Property Details

Property Type Residential Freehold
Sub-Type Semi-Detached
Style Bungalow
Living Area 900 sq ft
Bedrooms 5 (Above: 3, Below: 2)
Bathrooms 2 (Above: 1, Below: 1)
Kitchens 2
Basement Full, Finished, Separate Entrance
Lot Dimensions 42.75 × 98 ft
Lot Area 3,552.09 sq ft (Irregular)
Construction Brick
Foundation Block
Roof Asphalt Shingle
Approximate Age 51–99 Years
Heating Forced Air, Gas
Cooling None
Parking 4 Spaces — Private Double
Taxes $3,834 (2025)
Zoning ICBL, R2-K
Faces East

Features & Highlights

  • Legal Two-Unit Home — Ideal for First-Time Buyers & Investors
  • 5 Bedrooms & 2 Bathrooms Across Two Levels
  • Estimated Combined Rental Potential of ~$5,000/Month
  • Over $100,000 Invested in Renovations
  • Two Full Kitchens — One on Each Level
  • Finished Lower Level with Separate Entrance
  • Vacant & Move-In Ready — Choose Your Own Tenants
  • Open-Concept Living & Dining with Oversized Windows
  • Separate Laundry on Main and Lower Levels
  • Private Double Driveway with 4 Parking Spaces
  • In-Law Suite & Primary Bedroom on Main Floor
  • Established Newmarket Neighbourhood Near Parks, Schools & Transit

What Makes This Home Exceptional

Perfect for First-Time Buyers: Live in the lower unit and let the upper unit's estimated rental income of approximately $3,000 per month cover your monthly carrying costs. With an illustrative $600,000 mortgage at TD Bank's posted 5-year variable rate, estimated monthly payments would be approximately $2,965 — meaning rental income could effectively cover your mortgage while you build equity in your own home.


Strong Investment Returns: For investors, the estimated combined rental potential of approximately $5,000 per month ($3,000 upper unit and $2,000 lower unit) creates an excellent income-generating opportunity. With over $100,000 already invested in renovations, this home is move-in ready — allowing you to choose your own tenants or lease both units from day one with no additional renovation costs.


Connected Newmarket Location: Situated in an established neighbourhood, this home provides convenient access to parks, schools, shopping, public transit and everyday amenities. Easy connections to major commuter routes throughout York Region and the GTA make this an ideal location for families, professionals and investors looking for a well-connected property with strong rental demand.

Your Advisor

Neil Bayley-Hay

The Bayley-Hay Team is here to guide you through every step — with calm, clarity, and care.

Neil Bayley-Hay, Real Estate Advisor

Schedule a Showing

Interested in learning more about 43 Newbury Drive or exploring similar homes in Newmarket? Click below to open the scheduling form and we'll be happy to help. Click below to open our scheduling form and we'll be happy to help. Fill out your details and preferred viewing times, and a member of The Bayley-Hay Team will follow up promptly to confirm your showing.

Continue Your Search

Explore More Properties

Discover more listings across York Region and the Newmarket area. Whether you're a first-time buyer looking for a home with income potential, an investor seeking strong returns, or a family searching for the right fit — we'll help you find it.

Search All Properties Our Listings